The life of the famous French chanteuse with the thrilling voice, Edith Piaf, is the subject of a recently released film.La Vie En Rose, named after one of Piaf’s most well-known songs, just left Salem Cinema (Salem Oregon’s only art house and foreign film venue).
After seeing this recount of her successful career and her short and difficult life which began with her birth into desperate poverty in Belleville, and also being in the middle of viewing at home on DVD “La Commune,” a film by Peter Watkins (http://www.frif.com/new2002/la.html) about the Paris Commune of 1871, I began to think about a few “what if” scenarios.
What if the Commune - and the idea of a society run by workers themselves in their own interests, not those of their employers and exploiters - had succeeded? What things would have been different in Piaf’s life? Would Piaf’s father not have to leave Piaf’s mother and his child to join the military in order to survive? Would Piaf’s mother been less likely to have died in poverty and alcoholism, estranged from her daughter? Would all women and children have been less vulnerable and less likely to be subject to resorting to prostitution since it would be illegal, and female workers would have been able to make a living wage and be independent? Would Piaf have been able to go to a free and public school? Would there have been a healthy environment for all? Without either parent to take care of her, would a decent orphanage or other caring situation been available? Would there have been enforced laws against child labor? Would ordinary workers have been able to craft their workplace and society?
Another very famous Piaf song was “Non, je ne regrette rien” which translates as “No, I regret nothing.” It’s a brave and moving song, but I regret the suffering of the child that was Edith along with so many unknown others - when it did not have to be so.


